[ad_1]
Researchers at Oregon State University are challenging the premise that trophy hunting is an acceptable and effective tool for wildlife conservation and community development.
They argue that charging hunters to kill animals and claim body parts should be a last resort rather than a fallback plan.
In a paper published today in Conservation Letters, the researchers label the practice as morally inappropriate and say alternative strategies such as ecotourism should be fully explored and ruled out before trophy hunting is broadly endorsed.
“Trophies are body parts,” said lead author Chelsea Batavia, a Ph.D. student in OSU’s College of Forestry. “But when I read the literature, I don’t see researchers talking about them like that. Nobody’s even flinching. And at this point it seems to have become so normalized, no one really stops to think about what trophy hunting actually entails.”
Furthermore, the authors point out, the notion that trophy hunting is imperative to conservation seems to have taken hold largely without compelling empirical evidence. Such an assumption is not only unsubstantiated but can also serve to squelch the search for alternatives.
“Rejecting trophy hunting could open up space for innovation and creativity,” they write.
Batavia worked with colleagues in Oregon State’s Department of Forest Ecosystems and Society and collaborators from Canada and Australia. The idea for the paper occurred to them over the course of a review of scholarly literature on trophy hunting.
“Conservation scientists commonly recognize strong public opposition to the practice, and at times even point to some sort of ethical tension, but they don’t really define or address it,” Batavia said.
She and her co-authors decided it was time to break the silence and highlight an issue they suspect may underpin the public discomfort around trophy hunting — that it involves a hunter paying a fee to kill an animal and subsequently retaining some or all of the animal’s body as a trophy.
Part of the ongoing problem, the researchers write, is the word “trophy,” a sanitized expression for the tusks, ears, feet, heads, etc. that hunters remove from the animals’ bodies.
“It’s almost like an ethical distraction, calling it by some other name,” said co-author Michael Paul Nelson, a professor and the Ruth H. Spaniol Chair of Renewable Resources at OSU. “We have these metaphors that we hide behind. It’s like we recognize it’s an ethically loaded topic but we don’t know what to do about it. And we’ve tied conservation to the practice of trophy hunting — how do we get off that train?”
Proponents argue that trophy hunting supports conservation goals by generating money and reducing poaching and also that it bolsters local economies.
Nelson, Batavia and their co-authors recognize these benefits, but they counter that “collecting bodies or body parts as trophies is an ethically inappropriate way to interact with individual animals, regardless of the beneficial outcomes that do or do not follow.”
“We owe these animals some basic modicum of respect,” the researchers suggest. “To transform them into trophies of human conquest is a violation of common decency, and to accept trophy hunting as the international conservation community seems to have done is to aid and abet an immoral practice.”
If it’s determined that saving wildlife is inexorably linked to trophy hunting, conservationists should then “accept the practice only with a due appreciation of tragedy, and proper remorse,” the researchers write. They do acknowledge the possibility that future scientific research may suggest trophy hunting is in fact critical to the conservation mission in certain contexts.
“In that case trophy hunting should be used reluctantly,” they write. “The enthusiasm with which trophy hunting has already been championed as a potential conservation success story is misplaced. Trophy hunting violates the dignity of individual nonhuman animals, and is beneath our dignity as human beings. Continuing complicity by conservationists without fully exhausting other options is not now appropriate nor has it ever been.”
Joining Batavia and Nelson on the paper are Bill Ripple of OSU, Arian Wallach of the University of Technology Sydney, and Chris Darimont and Paul Paquet of the University of Victoria and the Raincoast Conservation Foundation.
[ad_2]
Source link
tadalafil 10mg canada – cost cialis 20mg cialis pills 20mg
purchase hydroxychloroquine pill – hydroxychloroquine 200mg ca plaquenil pill
buy stromectol 6mg – topical ivermectin cost ivermectin 12 mg without a doctor prescription
order cephalexin 125mg – order erythromycin 500mg pills order erythromycin pill
fildena 50mg drug – tamoxifen for sale order antabuse online cheap
purchase rhinocort online cheap – buy seroquel for sale ceftin 250mg canada
order bimatoprost – buy methocarbamol desyrel uk
sildenafil 100mg canada – order generic zantac zantac pills
buy tadalafil – can i buy stromectol online ivermectin oral
tadalafil 5mg generic – stromectol buy medicine for erectile
casino online slots – no deposit bonus codes prednisone 10mg drug
buy prednisone 40mg – accutane drug order generic isotretinoin 40mg
order amoxil 1000mg sale – sildenafil 100mg pills for men sildenafil for sale
order cialis 40mg for sale – buy cialis 5mg generic female cialis pill
ivermectin pills for humans – stromectol pills buy azithromycin 250mg without prescription
cost zithromax 250mg – buy generic furosemide methylprednisolone 4 mg otc
order generic baricitinib 4mg – aralen canada priligy 30mg tablet
metformin usa – order atorvastatin 20mg without prescription atorvastatin 20mg usa
generic amlodipine 5mg – order lisinopril 10mg sale prilosec 20mg without prescription
order clomiphene – zyrtec 5mg over the counter brand zyrtec 5mg
buy clarinex 5mg online cheap – order loratadine 10mg sale buy triamcinolone 10mg generic
generic misoprostol 200mcg – cost misoprostol 200mcg buy levothyroxine pills
generic sildenafil 100mg – order neurontin for sale gabapentin 800mg tablet
tadalafil 5mg cheap – buy cialis 20mg online cheap cenforce cost
oral diltiazem – buy generic zyloprim 100mg order acyclovir 800mg pills
atarax pills – buy hydroxyzine 10mg rosuvastatin 10mg generic
purchase zetia without prescription – oral citalopram 20mg celexa cheap
brand viagra – sildenafil for men over 50 flexeril over the counter
brand viagra 50mg – viagra pills 150mg buy cialis 10mg online
toradol for sale online – lioresal cost purchase lioresal generic
order colchicine – buy strattera 10mg without prescription atomoxetine price
purchase viagra generic – clopidogrel 75mg oral order plavix sale
viagra price – viagra overnight viagra us
nexium 20mg ca – order phenergan order promethazine
canadian cialis and healthcare – where to buy cialis buy cialis 10mg generic
order provigil without prescription – legal canadian prescription drugs online where to buy ed pills online
order accutane 10mg sale – buy amoxicillin 500mg generic order generic azithromycin 500mg
order furosemide 100mg sale – generic furosemide 100mg buy sildenafil 100mg for sale
buy tadalafil – buy viagra 100mg sale order viagra 50mg pills
tadalafil 40mg usa – purchase cialis for sale warfarin 2mg pill
buy generic topiramate – levofloxacin 250mg drug imitrex buy online
avodart uk – cialis 10mg usa order tadalafil 10mg for sale
order sildenafil 100mg pills – buy sildenafil generic pfizer cialis
medications for ed – prednisone 10mg drug prednisone 40mg sale
buy isotretinoin 10mg sale – buy isotretinoin 20mg online generic amoxicillin
buy furosemide generic – order lasix online order zithromax for sale
buy doxycycline online cheap – hydroxychloroquine 200mg us order chloroquine 250mg pill
cialis from canada – order sildenafil 50mg order generic sildenafil
order provigil 200mg for sale – viagra 150mg ca brand viagra 100mg
buy ed pill – cost prednisone 5mg deltasone 40mg drug
buy isotretinoin 20mg – order accutane 20mg online buy celecoxib for sale
order tamsulosin 0.4mg pill – order zofran 8mg sale order spironolactone 25mg for sale
buy simvastatin 10mg sale – cheap valacyclovir 1000mg help with assignments australia
play online casino real money – slots real money pay for research papers
casino real money – free slots online buy ampicillin 500mg sale
buy cipro 500mg generic – oral cialis tadalafil pill
sildenafil 100mg uk – indian generic vardenafil vardenafil generic date
order prednisolone 20mg online cheap – order gabapentin 800mg generic cialis overnight delivery
augmentin us – clavulanate pills buy tadalafil 20mg online cheap
purchase bactrim for sale – viagra next day delivery buy sildenafil 100mg generic
cost cephalexin 500mg – buy erythromycin pill order erythromycin 250mg for sale
provigil 100mg drug
modafinil 200mg uk purchase modafinil generic generic modafinil
generic provigil 100mg buy provigil
order modafinil online cheap purchase provigil sale
order ceftin – robaxin order cheap tadalafil 40mg
provigil online buy purchase provigil generic
uses for erythromycin
buy provigil
cheap provigil 200mg purchase modafinil online
purchase ampicillin generic – cost cipro buy generic tadalafil
order modafinil 200mg pills modafinil cost buy modafinil 100mg pills
modafinil medication modafinil 200mg pills purchase modafinil
amoxicillin 1000mg canada – order zithromax 500mg sale purchase levitra without prescription
erythromycin topical gel
stromectol ivermectin 3 mg – order vardenafil 20mg levitra 20mg uk
cheap doxycycline 100mg – order cialis pill tadalafil 20mg
4 azithromycin pills zithromax generic name medicine without dr prescription azithromycin [url=https://azithromycinfest.com/]azithromycin[/url] cost of z pak
tadalafil 20mg generic – online pharmacies canada buy provigil 200mg pills
buy erythromycin online erythromycin topical solution
cheap prednisone – order deltasone 5mg pill generic accutane 10mg
zithromax antibiotic for fish zithromax without a doctor prescription azithromycin 500 mg
order amoxicillin without prescription – purchase sildenafil generic sildenafil 50 mg
stromectol tablets for humans ivermectin for humans for sale
erythromycin cost without insurance https://erythromycinn.com/#
how to dose ivermectin to dogs stromectol
what is ventolin used for alternatives to ventolin hfa inhaler
generic prednisolone – prednisolone 40mg canada overnight delivery for viagra
buy furosemide 100mg for sale – buy lasix 100mg cost of stromectol
tbgcs
q74go
85bw
40 mg lasix too much
furosemide 40
furosemide
[url=https://furosemidevs.com/]furosemide 25 mg tablet[/url]
how does lasix work in the body
erythromycin and acne erythromycin dosage
plaquenil 200mg tablet – purchase baricitinib order baricitinib without prescription
albuterol side effects
how to use albuterol sulfate
cost of ventolin hfa inhaler
[url=https://ventolinusa.com/]albuterol cost[/url]
h7r60
v6t1r
[url=http://novrazbb.com/#]r9sn[/url]
ivermectin for humans for sale
ivermectin dosage chart for humans parasites
stromectol oral solution
[url=https://stromectolik.com/]ivermectin[/url]
lasix dosage for elderly
lasix 80mg
stopping lasix side effects
[url=https://furosemidevs.com/]furosemide 40 mg tablet[/url]
generic lasix
erythromycin ointment erythromycin ointment for newborns
buy lisinopril 10mg online – order lisinopril online atenolol online
t2wyp
9h4sc
9owl
levitra 20mg canada – methylprednisolone 8 mg over the counter buy clomiphene 50mg sale
order viagra europe viagra cheap fast shipping
albuterol 2mg brand – online casino order dapoxetine 30mg sale
buy asthma inhalers without an rx asthma medications inhalers
comfortis for dogs without vet prescription canadian drugs online
how to apply erythromycin erythromycin eye ointment side effects
https://drwithoutdoctorprescription.com/# canadian pharmacy
[url=https://drwithoutdoctorprescription.com/#]ed meds online without doctor prescription[/url] how to get prescription drugs without doctor
comfortis for dogs without vet prescription buy prescription drugs without doctor
viagra sale online ireland where to buy real viagra cialis online
buy synthroid without prescription – purchase plaquenil pills purchase plaquenil online cheap
where to buy viagra online buy viagra lloyds how to order generic viagra online
ventolin tablet crush ok ventolin generic price
ventrol inhaler cost of ventolin in usa
cialis 40mg pill – sildenafil 50mg pills for men buy sildenafil sale
hydroxychloroquine for sale over the counter hydroxychloroquine sulfate 200mg
ventolin albuterol [url=http://ventolin.directory/#]ventolin prescription uk [/url] albuterol sulfate inhalation solution price ventolin how many doses
zanaflex 2 mg tizanidine tab 4 mg how fast does zanaflex work how long do zanaflex overdose last
order prednisone 40mg for sale – order orlistat without prescription cheap amoxil generic
cheap viagra buy online buy viagra discreetly
[url=https://sildenafilmg.online/#]viagra cost per pill[/url] mexican viagra
purchase diltiazem for sale – order gabapentin online order gabapentin 600mg online cheap
best place to buy viagra online order viagra online
furosemide oral – order generic doxycycline order doxycycline 100mg
[url=https://sildenafilmg.shop/#]best over the counter viagra[/url] viagra from canada
mail order viagra australia http://bluethshop.com viagra tablet
online doctor prescription for viagra viagra
combivent vs ventolin [url=http://ventolin.directory/#]ventolin australia [/url] does albuterol help with coughing what color is the ventolin inhaler
order hydroxychloroquine online cheap alberta
order cenforce 50mg online – buy cenforce sale purchase domperidone
viagra price viagra over the counter walmart
https://sildenafilmg.shop/# over the counter viagra
[url=https://clomidforsale.life/#]clomid tablet online[/url] how to get clomid online
order viagra 50mg online cheap – cialis 20mg drug cheap cialis 10mg
zithromax 500 mg for sale zithromax 500mg price in india
buy amoxicillin 500mg buy amoxicillin without prescription
https://zithromaxforsale.shop/# zithromax for sale 500 mg
ventolin inhaler coupons printable albuterol inhaler with counter
[url=https://doxycyclineforsale.life/#]doxycycline pharmacy uk[/url] doxycycline prescription online
prednisone pharmacy prices prednisone 20
medicine diltiazem cardizem tablets diltiazem er vs diltiazem xr what are the worst side effects of diltiazem
where can i buy viagra online yahoo generic viagra cheap uk
buy online prescription drugs canadian drugstore
neurontin tab [url=https://neurontin.site/#]neurontin for sale online [/url] does neurontin show up on drug test gabapentin how to wean off
https://amoxilforsale.best/# how to get amoxicillin over the counter
[url=https://clomidforsale.life/#]medication clomid over the counter[/url] how can i get clomid online
doxycycline cap 40mg doxycycline 100mg capsules price in india
prednisone online australia prednisone 20mg nz
modafinil 100mg us – modafinil 200mg without prescription budesonide order
hydroxychloroquine 200mg tablets buy plaquenil 200mg buy 200mg hydroxychloroquine
where can i get zithromax over the counter can you buy zithromax over the counter in canada
generic zithromax online paypal zithromax 250mg
tadalafil online australia buy generic tadalafil
cost of lipitor in canada buy lipitor 10mg
[url=https://buymetformin.best/#]metformin 590 mg[/url] metformin 500 mg tablet buy online
https://buynolvadex.store/# femara vs tamoxifen
otc medication list pharmacies in canada shipping to usa
isotretinoin 10mg tablet – isotretinoin 20mg sale tetracycline 250mg pills
[url=https://buynolvadex.store/#]tamoxifen lawsuit[/url] tamoxifen menopause
https://buytadalafil.men/# tadalafil capsules 21 mg
purchase cyclobenzaprine without prescription – cost toradol buy inderal 20mg generic
kamagra tГ©moignage [url=http://kamagrafr.online/#]comment acheter du kamagra sans ordonnance [/url] faut il une ordonnance kamagra ou acheter du kamagra en pharmacie
viagra en anglais pfizer viagra 100mg viagra en france pas cher qui a deja acheter du viagra sur internet
canadian pharmacy tadalafil tadalafil best price uk
https://buylipitor.store/# lipitor 40 mg price australia
metformin 1000 tablet metformin order canada
generic for lasix http://furosemide.directory lasix generic
https://cipro.best/# cipro 500mg best prices
clopidogrel 75mg cheap – buy coumadin generic buy reglan 20mg without prescription
https://cipro.best/# buy generic ciprofloxacin
diflucan generic costs diflucan cream prescription
latisse active ingredient bimatoprost results where to purchase latisse online where can i buy latisse eyelash growth
https://erectionpills.best/# over the counter erectile dysfunction pills
order losartan 25mg for sale – order promethazine without prescription buy phenergan online cheap
cost for lasix furosemide 20 mg tabs
[url=https://cipro.best/#]buy ciprofloxacin over the counter[/url] ciprofloxacin over the counter
neurontin cost uk buy cheap neurontin online
https://withoutprescription.store/# buy canadian drugs
free aristocrat slots
[url=”https://2-free-slots.com”]bigslotscasinos[/url]
super slots online
https://erectionpills.best/# ed treatments
where can i buy cipro online buy cipro online without prescription
order levaquin pills – levaquin 500mg brand tadalafil 20mg cost
lasix 20mg [url=http://lasix.site/#]furosemide 40mg price [/url] when lasix doesn’t work for chf what happens if you take too much lasix
super kamagra tablets what is viagra for can you buy kamagra over the counter when to take cialis best time to take
https://diflucan.icu/# diflucan online cheap